The latest Hunger Games prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping, opened with a strong $56 million at the North American box office on Friday. The film, directed by Francis Lawrence, is expected to earn around $120 million by Sunday, far exceeding studio projections. It is the second prequel in the franchise, following 2023's The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, and brings the series' total global box office to more than $3.437 billion. The film centres on the origin story of Haymitch Abernathy, played by Joseph Zada, as he is forced to compete in the 50th Hunger Games, known as the Second Quarter Quell.

Director Francis Lawrence said a goal for Reaping was to function as a genuine entry point into the series for both new and old audiences. The film aims to stand entirely on its own merits, independent of viewers' experience with the other films. This is a lofty pair of goals, according to CBC News, with the film meeting the first as a relatively strong entry in the young adult post-apocalyptic genre. In confronting the second goal, however, the outlet said it ends up either failing outright or barely passing by crafting one of the more bizarrely morose entries in the chosen one narrative field.

A bleak story for newcomers

For those unfamiliar with the original trilogy, the film follows Haymitch Abernathy, a character later played by Woody Harrelson as a grizzled, traumatized mentor. Set 24 years before the first film, it shows Haymitch's selection as a tribute, tearing him away from his love, Lenore, played by Whitney Peak. The story includes typical setup markers, like Haymitch saving Lenore by volunteering himself and a plan from the mysterious Beetee Latier to take down the Capitol from inside the games. The central conflict is that if Haymitch follows this plan, he will not get out alive.

Because this is a backstory for a character alive in later films, his survival is preordained. This knowledge diminishes the experience, according to CBC News, by turning what was once hinted-at trauma into explicit, prolonged suffering. The film's back half features what the outlet described as about 30 minutes of screaming, montage-based alcoholism and more tiny coffins than a Dracula-themed dollhouse. For a newcomer, instead of a story about victory over fascism, we get a cruel rug-pull that lacks both a cohesive emotional framing and message, said CBC News.

The Substack review echoed that the film is overly self-serious and becomes tedious. The adapted screenplay by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie desperately needed a bit of wit and humour to contrast the avalanche of dystopian tragedy, the review stated. It also criticized the film's ropey CGI and noted that grislier sequences from the book have been watered down. The review concluded there is no great reason for more casual viewers to rush out and see this, especially if you haven't seen the earlier films.

Undercutting the original series

A major critique from IGN is that the prequel's additions detract from Haymitch's character rather than enrich him. In the original films, Haymitch undergoes a powerful arc from a broken alcoholic to a key player in the rebellion, inspired by Katniss Everdeen's hope. Sunrise on the Reaping concludes with a voice-over where Haymitch vows to be a terrible victor and to eventually end the Games, followed by a flash-forward showing an older Haymitch at peace after the Reaping has ended. This conclusion creates a narrative problem, according to IGN. Turning the original Hunger Games story into the fulfillment of Haymitch’s long-delayed goal undercuts the power of those first films. The outlet argues that if the hope and intention were always there, then the transformation we thought we witnessed wasn't real, and suddenly one of the franchise’s best character journeys loses its meaning. IGN stated that a prequel’s one job is to deepen the original, and this one weakens it.

The film also introduces a plot point where the Capitol edits footage of Haymitch's games to make him look ruthless and cowardly, a tactic IGN said creates a real problem for the original films. The Substack review warned that an epilogue in Reaping ruins the outcome of the original three films on multiple fronts for those who haven't seen them, advising against watching the series in chronological order. Despite the criticism, the film features performances from Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, and Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket. Joseph Zada's portrayal of Haymitch was called beautiful by IGN and a standout. The film is now playing in theaters.