Fewer American renters are becoming homeowners than 16 years ago, according to a new report. TransUnion found the share of renters transitioning to homeownership fell from 7.2% in 2009 to 3.9% in 2025, a decline of nearly half. The analysis measures the rate of transition rather than total sales volume. It shows a significantly smaller portion of renters are able to buy a home compared to the past.
One major barrier is affordability, as rising prices and mortgage rates strain budgets. "Rising home prices and mortgage rates have made monthly payments unmanageable for many prospective buyers," Ryan Thomson of The Assumable Guy told Realtor.com. He cited Colorado Springs, where the share of households able to afford a median-priced home dropped from 71% in 2019 to 25.3% in 2023. Other costs like property taxes, insurance and maintenance can also push ownership out of reach.
First-time buyers are also getting older, according to separate research. The National Association of Realtors found the median age of first-time buyers remained at a record 40 in 2026, compared to 30 in 2010. This decade-long delay can postpone life plans like renovating a kitchen or planting a permanent garden. Homeownership also brings unpredictable costs, from a failing furnace to a damaged roof, which can drain savings.
Some households consider moving to less expensive states, but that brings new financial considerations. TransUnion identified Texas, Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina and Tennessee as top destinations for inbound migration. However, all five states face higher risks from hurricanes and severe storms than many places people are leaving. These weather risks often mean higher insurance costs and potential repair bills.
Real estate expert Cameron Walker noted that popularity can itself drive up costs in these Sun Belt markets. "Growing demand in popular Sun Belt destinations can also drive up property values, taxes, and insurance premiums," Walker of Clever Real Estate told Realtor.com. He said moving for a lower price does not guarantee lasting affordability. Walker suggested expanding the supply of affordable starter homes and improving financing options could help more renters. The TransUnion report does not indicate how many renters actually want to buy a home. It simply shows the transition from renting to owning is happening far less often than it once did. For those who do aspire to own, the dream of putting down permanent roots now requires more time, more money and greater financial security than in previous generations.