The president of the Halifax International Security Forum said Friday that American leadership has become unreliable. Peter Van Praagh told attendees that other nations must now chart a new path forward. He said the policies of U.S. President Donald Trump are testing long standing alliances. "Without the United States as a predictable leader, people, institutions and countries are looking for a new course. A North Star," Van Praagh said in his opening remarks. He added that while no single nation can match U.S. power, upholding democratic ideals is a shared responsibility.

Trump commented on Canada the same day after meeting with Prime Minister Mark Carney in China. The U.S. president said Canadians had become emboldened in dealings with Washington. "For some reason they feel emboldened. We can't let them feel that way anymore," Trump said. His administration has repeatedly threatened to annex Canada and has imposed tariffs straining relations. In response, Carney has worked to forge stronger links with Europe, China and other partners to lessen Canada's reliance on the United States.

Van Praagh, a former senior adviser to Conservative foreign affairs minister Peter MacKay, had previously warned about Trump's potential reaction to the U.S. midterm elections. In a pre election essay sent to security officials, he wrote that Trump would try to undermine the results if Republicans lost badly. "If these efforts are successful, it will be the end of the United States as we know it," Van Praagh wrote. He did not join Canadian Defence Minister David McGuinty for the forum's traditional joint opening press conference, breaking with past practice.

McGuinty echoed recent comments from Carney about a shifting global order. "Institutions like NATO have always been vital to our collective security. They just can't be our only way of working together. Those days are over," McGuinty said. The Trump administration prevented Pentagon officials from attending the forum under 2025 restrictions on think tank events. Earlier administrations from both parties regularly sent senior U.S. military leaders to the Halifax meeting.

A bipartisan group of U.S. lawmakers is participating this weekend. Democratic Senator Chris Coons of Delaware criticized Trump's participation in a recent summit with Chinese and Russian leaders. Coons referenced a photo showing Chinese President Xi Jinping seated centrally between Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. "Putin and Trump look diminished," Coons said. "I saw an America diminished by Trump appealing to China to let us be a part of the leadership of the world." He concluded, "It is the wrong man in the wrong place at the wrong time, sending exactly the wrong message." The Halifax International Security Forum is in its 18th year. It typically hosts around 300 military officials, diplomats, scholars and American legislators at the Westin Nova Scotian hotel.